December 11, 20178 yr So as the title says, the crankbaits are completely broken. What was once my go-to lure for many species and especially in certain comps is now rendered useless. I've noticed several problems with them now. Sure, you're still going to catch the oddball fish, but nowhere near what you used to. I enjoy the new physics for the most part, but think they should take crankbaits back to EXACTLY what they were pre-patch. The best lures in the game are now virtually useless. Problems I have found with crankbaits so far. 1: Slow diving time. Even increasing your reel speed at the beginning of the retrieve to acquire the desired depth is not working. They take forever to dive to the "proper" depth(I'll get into this next). Reeling at a higher speed initially also takes the crank out of the desired zone/hotspot that you want to fish. Making it near impossible to target fish. 2: Max depth is no longer accurate. I'll give an example. Previously, before the patch, I would go to the Infinite Tunnels peg in Florida. Cast down the center of the middle "tunnel/channel" with a 16ft crankbait. It was the perfect depth to just reach the bottom and bounce up and down with a steady speed 2 retrieve. 12 ft wouldn't fully reach the bottom, and 23 ft would drag along the bottom and never come up. This indicated that the bottom was around 16 ft deep. Now, not only does the 16 ft crankbait not bounce off the bottom anymore which was the #1 way to get Unique LMB for me, ALL depths of crankbaits dive all the way to the bottom excluding 3ft. The 6ft, 8ft, 12ft, 16ft, 23ft, and 30 ft all behave the same regarding max swimming depth. 3: Bouncing off the bottom no longer works. You can no longer cast out using the perfect depth crank to reach the bottom and have it bounce off the bottom whilst retrieving. I have tried every speed, setup, and depth. I even tried simulating it by using a stop and go retrieve along the bottom which doesn't work other than catching the random fish here and there. This is a huge negative, as when the crankbait used to come up off the bottom, that's when the majority of strikes used to come. Now they won't bite with it directly on the bottom(even worse when all depths of cranks dive all the way to the bottom). 4: X-Series Crankbaits are invisible. Not a game killer, but I just won my first top 3 finally in a competition to get my coveted 8ft #6/0 X-Series crankbait. They do not appear at all on screen. You just see your line hanging off into the aether. Regarding Topwater, I have yet to find an appropriate setup when using any of the new topwater lures. Of course you can use an Aurora, or a Jigwinner to get a good casting distance, but it's near impossible to get the proper action using either of these setups, not to mention VERY difficult to target any fish over 10 lbs using this setup. Which is primarily what you're going for. You can use them on heavier rigs such as the Loki(which should be the minimum and target setup for topwater), but seeing as 3/4oz(21g) is the largest topwater you can get and the Loki starts out at 7/8oz lure rating, you can't even cast out far enough to target the fish you desire. As well as not being able to get a full 3 dot retrieve with them, 2 dot for that matter. You guys at FP should really include the full gamut of sizes, just like every other lure in the game for topwater. Everything from tiny 1/6oz poppers for panfish to use on ultralight rods. The existing topwaters for light/medium rods such as the aurora and jigwinner, in the 1/2 - 3/4oz sizes. Then for the Loki - Zeus range of rods, include some 1-2oz lures so we can fish for the uniques and monsters without using too light of gear to catch them, as well as not sacrificing casting distance. Overall, I enjoy the new physics visually. Everything looks and feels a lot smoother. However, that should take a step down to how things work mechanically in the game. Nobody wants a pretty game that doesn't play well. A parallel to this, I play guitar. I'd much rather have a hideously ugly guitar that plays and sounds great, than a fancy beautifully ornate guitar that plays and sounds like crap.
December 11, 20178 yr A comment, if I may dude? We have spent a lot of time on lakes together and have chatted our pads into oblivion, so I hope you know I'm simply talking straight. From what I can tell, all that has changed regarding cranks is the indicator in the top right. All the old retrieves still work as they used to when the indicator was ambiguous at best. I ignore it now for cranks ( and only cranks ) because I can reel in 50 feet of line with my crank a few feet down and then all of a sudden it'll plummet to the bottom in the space of 5 feet. The old one was iffy, this one is iffy. Seems accurate enough on spinners, spoons etc though. Regarding topwaters, this is a very tough area to try to replicate. My thinking is that strike and rod twitch need to be 2 different buttons, as the line is up and down like a whores draws which screws the retrieve when slack is introduced, which you can avoid when using topwaters for real. Since the update we seem to get resonance loops in he line when stop/starting. And I have done A LOT of surface fishing lately ;-) Like I said, a tough one to replicate. Just my thoughts mate, hope to see you in there again sometime.
December 11, 20178 yr Author Always happy to hear your opinion on things VV. It does appear that our experiences differ greatly though. 5 minutes ago, Violentvole said: All the old retrieves still work as they used to when the indicator was ambiguous at best. I'll have to disagree. I did some pretty extensive testing. Using the same crankbait, rod, reel, and reel speed and location. Which was the Loki 8'10", Hornet Swarm 5000, 16ft #4/0 crankbait, reel speed 2. At the Infinity Tunnels, I caught 2 fish out of 100+ casts over 4 in game hours and just gave up and left the waterway. This is opposed to using the exact same technique pre-patch where it bounced off the bottom. I would catch a fish nearly every single cast. Bare minimum 1 out of 3 casts. This was including trophies and uniques. I experienced the same problem with the 12ft #2/0 crankbait that I previously used to slay bass at Neherrin. It's about the same crappy reduced ratio. I surely hope the same problem doesn't exist with Salmon in Alaska, otherwise the comps there will be rendered pointless. Not to mention the upcoming Tournament. That's also not including that all of the crankbaits dive to the bottom excluding the 3 ft crankbait now. 14 minutes ago, Violentvole said: My thinking is that strike and rod twitch need to be 2 different buttons, as the line is up and down like a whores draws which screws the retrieve when slack is introduced, which you can avoid when using topwaters for real. Since the update we seem to get resonance loops in he line when stop/starting. Agreed. Lift and drop is very difficult as well on some setups now as well that it was not previously a problem. That's due to the line slack issue. We still definitely need a much fuller range of sizes for Topwaters though as I stated above. Every other lure class has an entire range of sizes. 43 minutes ago, X-xH3aDxS4o7x-X said: You guys at FP should really include the full gamut of sizes, just like every other lure in the game for topwater. Everything from tiny 1/6oz poppers for panfish to use on ultralight rods. The existing topwaters for light/medium rods such as the aurora and jigwinner, in the 1/2 - 3/4oz sizes. Then for the Loki - Zeus range of rods, include some 1-2oz lures so we can fish for the uniques and monsters without using too light of gear to catch them, as well as not sacrificing casting distance.
December 11, 20178 yr It seems a lot of us have different experiences. I'm not discounting anything you say - far from it - but can only go with my own experiences, as we all have to. I'll stick with my topwater experimentation while they do whatever needs doing to cranks. I honestly have no problem with cranks right now, but I have seen that more than a few do. In the same vein though, there're people saying they have no problems with them also. One thing I have noticed is that larger species will now nibble for anywhere up to a minute when float fishing - strike was done too soon. I've had my float totally submerged several times and struck, only to get Strike was done too soon.
December 11, 20178 yr Author So....just did some more testing in Alaska. The 16ft crankbait that never went to the bottom there, now goes to the bottom and you can only get bites if it's before it reaches the bottom. This is beyond frustrating. So much for the Kaniq comps. I guess I could use other methods, but they are without a doubt 100% broken.
December 11, 20178 yr if a crank hits bottom stop reelling, let it rise, but not to the top crank some more rinse and repeat fish will sometimes strike it as you stop, and as it rises
December 11, 20178 yr Author 1 minute ago, mdram said: if a crank hits bottom stop reelling, let it rise, but not to the top crank some more rinse and repeat fish will sometimes strike it as you stop, and as it rises The problem is, ALL crankbaits of ALL depths go all the way to the bottom now. They no longer bounce off the bottom either. The stop and go technique to pull them off the bottom is not even 1/1000 as effective as it was pre-patch. They are not behaving like they should. A 6ft crankbait should not hit bottom where previously a 16ft crankbait barely reached bottom.
December 12, 20178 yr I think what the OP is saying here has been an issue for a long time now- since water depths were reconfigured many months ago. Before the change you could use a 30ft crank- now they all just get left at home. All deeper cranks never get used anymore except maybe in Alberta. Sinking lures don't work right either. Try Alberta- let your spoon (or jig, spinner, etc.) sink to the bottom and it goes haywire- completely out of control. You still catch fish but wow- the lure action is crazy. Frequently it's like you're pulling the lure thru heavy mud trying to do a stop and go or lift and drop-- like the bottom is magnetized. It'd be great if you could control the depth of the lure with your retrieve more.
December 12, 20178 yr I’m glad Headshot expanded on broken cranks. They are starting to annoy. Basically, one of the most effective baits to just relax with is totally fubar currently. I hope there is a remedy in the pipeline.
December 12, 20178 yr For me - and just for me - it's the indicator that is broken. All cranks and retrieves still work as before. As an angler irl the angle of the line from rod tip tells me a lot. And although the indicator may tell me my crank is dragging bottom or just below the surface, a glance at the angle of the line shows it's fubar. I simply ignore it and use common sense.
December 18, 20178 yr Jigwinner, BassCaster, Thora, even the Zeus are great for topwater lures. I put my frog-popper on my Zeus and go after muskie in Michigan, and even though the 5/8oz lure is too light for the 3/4-2 1/8oz rod, I can still cast out 160ft. You're never going to get 3 dots using topwater lures. PC players can't even achieve that. You can consistently hit 2 using any of the rods. The further out the cast is, the higher you have to bring the pole up when popping. When it is closer in, you don't have to bring it up as high, even tilting down is enough. I started off popping and then once the line got straightened back out I would pop again. Using the Counsellor 3500S, reeling on a 1 speed, it works out to about 1 1/2 to 2 turns of the reel between each pop. It stays at 2 all the way up to when it comes flying in. With a reel under 30 recovery it's around 2 to 2 a 1/2 reels between each one. The best thing I can tell you is that the further out it is, the higher the pole needs to be to get it to make the motion to dusturb the water and make the popping noise. It doesn't have to be extremely high. I leave mine pointed straight out to begin and then adjust if needed, then as it comes in I tilt it down some since it no longer needs to come up as high to do what's needed. Honestly just keep messing with it and it will come to you. They work with a lot of setups.
December 18, 20178 yr Jigwinner, BassCaster, Thora, even the Zeus are great for topwater lures. I put my frog-popper on my Zeus and go after muskie in Michigan, and even though the 5/8oz lure is too light for the 3/4-2 1/8oz rod, I can still cast out 160ft. You're never going to get 3 dots using topwater lures. PC players can't even achieve that. You can consistently hit 2 using any of the rods. The further out the cast is, the higher you have to bring the pole up when popping. When it is closer in, you don't have to bring it up as high, even tilting down is enough. I started off popping and then once the line got straightened back out I would pop again. Using the Counsellor 3500S, reeling on a 1 speed, it works out to about 1 1/2 to 2 turns of the reel between each pop. It stays at 2 all the way up to when it comes flying in. With a reel under 30 recovery it's around 2 to 2 a 1/2 reels between each one. The best thing I can tell you is that the further out it is, the higher the pole needs to be to get it to make the motion to dusturb the water and make the popping noise. It doesn't have to be extremely high. I leave mine pointed straight out to begin and then adjust if needed, then as it comes in I tilt it down some since it no longer needs to come up as high to do what's needed. Honestly just keep messing with it and it will come to you. They work with a lot of setups.
December 18, 20178 yr Cranks in Alberta is fun, stuck on the bed of river. Acting as a fish is on ( with none ) in and out of the water, and flying cranks ! fun times Edited December 18, 20178 yr by CrackBadger The fun of a flying crank bait
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.