March 3, 20188 yr I've been playing this game for about a month now, and have noticed something quite bothersome. As of the time of this post, the strongest float rod can handle 16kg of line weight. Right now, available in the shop in game, there's a 17kg spin reel with 8 drag settings, and a 19kg reel, also with 8 drag settings. Nothing in between. However, if you look at the DLC Char Charger's Pack, you'll notice there is an 18kg reel in the package. There is no equivalent to this reel that can be obtained without using real money. Why is this a problem? If you look at the 17kg reel, with the drag set to 7/8, it'll give 14.875 kg of drag. This is safe for both 15.8kg line and the 16kg match rod. The 19kg reel at 7/8 drag is 16.625kg, which is too high so we'd have to go to 6/8 drag to be safe, but overall lower than the 17kg's highest safest, coming in at 14.25kg. The CCO FireBall 6000 reel also has 8 drag settings, and set to 7/8 that would give you 15.75kg. This is within safe limits for both the strongest float rod in the game, and the 15.8kg line. That makes this reel the strongest reel in the game when it comes to floating, and this reel is only available for real money. This is the exact definition of Pay2Win. What's more worrying, is that the DLC in question has been out almost a year. Will an equivalent of this reel ever come out for purchase in the in game shop, or will the best of the best be reserved for those who spend money?
March 4, 20188 yr Author I would also like to add that I am in no way against spending money on a free to play game. In fact I encourage it. This game I feel deserves support, and it's been very fun and the community is friendly and helpful. Within the Free to Play format, however, there is a moral directive that must be taken into account. There will be players that won't, or simply can't afford to purchase a DLC, and they will be at a disadvantage compared to those who can. But isn't that true for all free to play games? Spend money, gain an advantage? Technically, yes. There are many free to play games that I play, and I have supported them through purchases, and I did gain an advantage. The advantages gained, however, never impacted performance permanently. The advantages are either temporary, or convenience related, or cosmetic. Anything obtained that improves performance can be earned through time/skill. That is not the case with this reel. As things are, a free to play player will never be able to achieve the same performance as one who bought the Char Charger's Pack. Even if there was one in the shop that could be purchased only with baitcoins, it is still something that could be worked towards, as there are ways to earn baitcoins without spending money. If you are a developer of this game and happen to read this, please take this information into consideration when moving forward. I want to see this game grow, and improve. There are many things that could remedy this issue. Releasing an 18kg spin reel to the in game shop for baitcoins or in game cash is one. Another is introducing a float rod with max line weight of 17kg or more. As the game gets bigger, I am sure eventually better gear will come out, perhaps more levels. Something that would make the CCO FireBall 6000 obsolete. But for the time being, I feel it is important to shed some light on the current state of things. For the vast majority of players, this might not matter. There might not even be a fish out there in the waters of Fishing Planet that would mathematically require the increased pulling power that the FireBall 6000 delivers over other reels when float fishing, but the advantage is still there. It's the principle of the situation.
March 24, 20188 yr while the CCO FireBall 6000 reel is good for maximising 1 rod type based off the 3m Brutus float rod with 16kg (35lb) max line capacity to within ~0.2kg of its braking point provided your using metric units, (if your using imperial units the rod and line have the same 35lb braking strength) it is generally NOT what you would use it for, because your Brutus 16kg rod will wear out before the line, as the 0.55mm 15.8kg fluoro line has a health pool that is larger than the health pool of the 3m 16kg Brutus rod, thus at all drag levels the reel will provide <15.75kg the line will actually wear slower than the rod if using metric units, while with imperial being as the equivalent line is 35lb and the rod is 35lb you will damage the rod even faster, as the rods health pool will deplete sooner than the line, as the line has a larger health pool. BTW: at one time the reel that is currently rated at 19kg were rated at 18kg, but this was changed because of the imperial related problems and the fact that back then there was no 15.8kg (35lb) line there was only really 14.5kg as an option which 19kg on the 6th drag setting (14.25kg), 16kg on the 7th drag setting (14kg) were aligned much better than the 13.5kg the 18kg variant could yield. now if you were to use CCO FireBall 6000 reel on big spinning rods >19.5kg, you could use 15.8kg (35lb) line without incurring such silliness as your line outlasting your rod regardless of if metric or imperial units are used, while the RiverTex ThunderSpin 5500 and its derivatives that are all rated at 19kg still have the edge on being able to use 18.1kg line at 16.625kg drag. so really there is NO pay to win there, but you could say there is pay to increase you repair cost and shorten your stay at fishing places if you use the CCO FireBall 6000 reel with 1 specific rod type based on the 3m Brutus float rod with 16kg (35lb) max line capacity, if your willing to accept a shorter casting distance than the 3.6m Brutus float rod equipped with 0.5mm mono line and a RiverTex ThunderSpin 5500.
March 24, 20188 yr Author 11 hours ago, b101uk said: while the CCO FireBall 6000 reel is good for maximising 1 rod type based off the 3m Brutus float rod with 16kg (35lb) max line capacity to within ~0.2kg of its braking point provided your using metric units, (if your using imperial units the rod and line have the same 35lb braking strength) it is generally NOT what you would use it for, because your Brutus 16kg rod will wear out before the line, as the 0.55mm 15.8kg fluoro line has a health pool that is larger than the health pool of the 3m 16kg Brutus rod, thus at all drag levels the reel will provide <15.75kg the line will actually wear slower than the rod if using metric units, while with imperial being as the equivalent line is 35lb and the rod is 35lb you will damage the rod even faster, as the rods health pool will deplete sooner than the line, as the line has a larger health pool. BTW: at one time the reel that is currently rated at 19kg were rated at 18kg, but this was changed because of the imperial related problems and the fact that back then there was no 15.8kg (35lb) line there was only really 14.5kg as an option which 19kg on the 6th drag setting (14.25kg), 16kg on the 7th drag setting (14kg) were aligned much better than the 13.5kg the 18kg variant could yield. now if you were to use CCO FireBall 6000 reel on big spinning rods >19.5kg, you could use 15.8kg (35lb) line without incurring such silliness as your line outlasting your rod regardless of if metric or imperial units are used, while the RiverTex ThunderSpin 5500 and its derivatives that are all rated at 19kg still have the edge on being able to use 18.1kg line at 16.625kg drag. so really there is NO pay to win there, but you could say there is pay to increase you repair cost and shorten your stay at fishing places if you use the CCO FireBall 6000 reel with 1 specific rod type based on the 3m Brutus float rod with 16kg (35lb) max line capacity, if your willing to accept a shorter casting distance than the 3.6m Brutus float rod equipped with 0.5mm mono line and a RiverTex ThunderSpin 5500. You're saying that I am talking about 1 specific setup. You clearly missed the understanding of "best" here. There are two types of fishing in this game, float and lure. This is not for one specific setup among many, many setups. This is literally the most performance you can get for half of what the game has to offer. It's not silly, either. The fact that you are defending this type of business practice blows my mind. There is no argument here. If you're float fishing and you want the most pull power, There is nothing better. Period. Line outlasting rod means absolutely nothing either, and you claiming higher repair costs is a joke. Yes, there is pay2win here. Also, on imperial the rod might say 35lb in the display, but it is just a UI reading. Rods do not change their kg rating unlike line and reel. You will still get 16kg, which is 35.274lb so the line will wear out before the rod durability to durability. Not that that matters in the slightest. Edited March 24, 20188 yr by PapaKlump
March 24, 20188 yr Author Since we're on the subject of line vs rod durability, let's take the current strongest non-DLC float setup in the game as an example, which is the Brutus 11'10" with a Thunderspin 5000 and 35lb test. The rod's rated for 33lb, and the reel is 37lb with 8 drag settings making 7/8 give you 32.375lb of pull power. This is safe for the rod as long as you don't let yourself get spooled. And with this setup the rod will definitely wear out before the line. That does not matter, but if it did, the difference in wear between these two parts in this setup is greater than the actual strongest setup with the Brutus 9'10" with FireBall 6000. Would you prefer a setup that'll last you a long time at a waterway and a minimally smaller repair cost? I respect and encourage you to do it. But your performance is going to take a hit in doing so. A Brutus rod with a Thunderspin 5500 and 0.5mono will give you 31.5lb of pull power. The line will break before anything else, and that's all fine and dandy. But with CCO FireBall 6000, you get 35lb of pull power. 35 > 31.50 35 > 32.375 This should not be a hard concept to grasp.
March 24, 20188 yr 4 hours ago, PapaKlump said: You're saying that I am talking about 1 specific setup. You clearly missed the understanding of "best" here. There are two types of fishing in this game, float and lure. This is not for one specific setup among many, many setups. This is literally the most performance you can get for half of what the game has to offer. It's not silly, either. The fact that you are defending this type of business practice blows my mind. There is no argument here. If you're float fishing and you want the most pull power, There is nothing better. Period. Line outlasting rod means absolutely nothing either, and you claiming higher repair costs is a joke. Yes, there is pay2win here. Also, on imperial the rod might say 35lb in the display, but it is just a UI reading. Rods do not change their kg rating unlike line and reel. You will still get 16kg, which is 35.274lb so the line will wear out before the rod durability to durability. Not that that matters in the slightest. Given all the high end spinning rods are all rated at 19.5kg or more, and the RiverTex ThunderSpin 5500 (19kg) can yield 16.625kg of drag on the 7th setting and the reel and rod are both stronger than the 18.1kg line, while the CCO FireBall 6000 (18kg) is weaker than the line braking load and can only muster 15.75kg drag on the 7th setting, the RiverTex ThunderSpin 5500 (19kg) and its 19kg derivatives are clearly “best”, so no “pay2win” there, so that’s the lure rods out of the equation unless your going to argue the ones best served by 9.1kg lines, but then I will point out that the reels rated at 12kg max drag with 12 drag increments also produce exactly 9kg of drag that same as CCO FireBall 6000 (18kg) dose on its 4th drag setting. So this leaves in terms of rods just the 3m 16kg Brutus float rod (and 3m 16kg derivatives), which in my book is “1 specific setup” i.e. 1 rod type, 1 line type and 1 reel type, which has some disadvantages too of wear and longevity, shorter casting distance and higher repair costs vs. the 3.6m 15kg variants running 14.5kg line at 14.25kg drag with the RiverTex ThunderSpin 5500 (19kg) on the 6th drag setting. As for imperial vs. metric, yes some descriptive elements like dimensions are rounded in the UI for simple clarity, but when it comes to reel drag for instance there are subtle changes between imperial and metric variant, because simply rounding something in the UI for instance saying a reel has 35lb max drag when it really has 35.27396lb (16kg) drag, would make it relatively imposable for people using the imperial UI to divide max drag by the number of drag steps to arrive at an accurate #.####lb per increment, which would be further compounded then to by rounding of line strength, so 15.8kg line is 35lb, it is not 34.83304lb. You clearly don’t understand durability, the Brutus 300 3m 16kg rod has 36000hp, 0.55mm 15.8kg fluoro line has 37500hp, meaning the line has ~4.1666% more HP than rod, but there is only ~1.55% between the 16kg max rod load and the 15.75kg reel drag, so while the line may be at ~99.7% and the rod be at 98.45% load it still falls short of the <95.8334% load it would need to be at to outlast the line, assuming both the rod and the line has 100% of their respective HP at the start, likewise if you had a CCO FireBall 6000 (18kg) and had attached it to a Brutus 300 3m 16kg rod with 15.8kg fluoro line and had gone fishing with it and regardless of the drag setting you selected (7th or lower) you will have observed your rods health trending downward faster than that of your 15.8kg fluoro line as I have. As for your second post, you seem to forget “best” is subjective, best practice would be to have line as the weakest part and not the rod, best practice for lower repair cost is not to have expensive items like rods and reels at high loads relative to the cheap component that line is, best casting distance comes from longer rods, thinner line or more mass being cast, being able to fish at place for longer rather than being limited by your rod wearing out prematurely is best for making money, in fact there are far more “bests” than the singular best of 15.75kg load that comes with a load of compromises, additional cost and other deficiencies which are clearly NOT “best’s”.
March 25, 20188 yr Author You're comparing Spin setups to Float setups. I have said absolutely nothing subjective. The CCO FireBall 6000 gives you the strongest float setup in the game period. That is not up for debate. The numbers are there. I understand durability enough to know that it does not matter at all in terms of the argument you're trying to make. Non-stop pike farming Michigan for 2 weeks straight is what it takes to wear out the "more costly" setup. This is assuming for the entire two weeks you use max safe drag setting. Most fish will pull in easy with another tick down on the drag setting and exponentially reduce the durability loss throughout a trip. You're making it sound like the difference in repair costs is massive, when in actual reality it's very, very small. Unlike the over 8% pulling power you get with the FireBall 6000. That's a noticeable difference. It's good practice to have the line be the weakest part of the setup if you don't know what you're doing, but for those familiar with what the B button does by default. It doesn't matter at all if the line is the strongest part of the setup or not. How is 35 > 31.5 subjective? It's not. I am stating facts, not opinion here. The strongest float setup in the game, the power in which you can pull in a fish, requires money to obtain. It is unmatched.
March 25, 20188 yr Author I feel like the overall intention of this post has been lost. My intention is to say that I would like to see equal opportunity for everyone in game, whatever an individual chooses to do. What I am trying to ultimately say is ANY permanent advantage that one can have in a game that requires money to get is wrong. It is wrong. Durability and repair costs have nothing to do with this at all. I do not understand why anyone would have to defend pointing out issues. And listen, I'm not bashing this game or its developers at all. I'm pointing out a slight, but valid problem, that's all. How does durability and repair costs have any remote relation to the issue? It doesn't. Edited March 25, 20188 yr by PapaKlump
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.