June 15, 20188 yr When the surface lures first appeared I spent a few weeks traveling and testing what would take what. Turned out damn near everything takes everything, only cost me 400k. I digress. However, Walleye, Whitefish, Brown Trout and Tiger Trout eluded me on topwaters, and Jim and I believe TC was also testing them? And then, after weeks and weeks of trying back in November (?) I was after a uni perch in Michigan earlier on a popper and a 5lb Brownie showed up. From the lighthouse, on a surface lure. I spent countless hours flogging Sandy Cape trying to get a Brownie on a surface lure lol. I love this randomness, getting gar from uni Bowfin, Channel Cats and Flathead spots in Louisiana. However, I've yet to meet anyone who has had a Walleye on a surface lure.. I know some guys have had surprise Tarpon in Florida and I recall Jim getting a uni LMB from Salty Delta and a Chinook on peas in Cali ( I was there for that one ). I managed a LMB on large cutbait once. What have you caught that you shouldn't have? Do not reply with: shells, boots, weed, turtles etc.
June 15, 20188 yr Caught a 19lb Snook yesterday 50ft from the upturned boat in Florida with a 1oz pumpkin Bass jig.....I thought I was onto the biggest Bass ever caught on FP......fought like a bugger!
June 15, 20188 yr The devs once posted that it is possible to catch random fish at the wrong places. I have experienced it most in FL.
June 15, 20188 yr Just a few I can remember: Uni Tiger Trout, 4" Newt, far right hand corner at Sandy Cape. Uni Northern Pike, 4" Shad, off the dock near the Uni Clear Muskie spot. Uni Largemouth, #3/0 Yellow & Red Casting Spoon, left side of Salty Delta. Uni Walleye, Pike Alley. Uni Smallmouth, Tiger Musky spot. Trophy Red Drum, #4/0 Popper, Salty Delta. Chinock Salmon, Peas, In California. Most recently, during the round one qualifier at Michigan, 28lb Blue Cat on a 12' #6/0 Crank at the Light House. Edited June 15, 20188 yr by J.Mitchell WV
June 15, 20188 yr Power Members My best one was a largemouth Bass on corn while fishing Carp in California. I was utterly surprised, it only happend 1 time and i fished there extensivly
June 15, 20188 yr I can get walleye in New York but not Michigan . Fish towards evening by weeds. I also got a Tarpon but i think it was a fluke all by using Topwater lures . The biggest shock was when i was fishing for Oscar with a light weight pole ended up with a Unique snook Edited June 15, 20188 yr by Hate_ful
June 15, 20188 yr Trying to catch the one that got away at my pike spot, partway down the shoreline of the eastern bank, heading towards pike alley using shiners on a 42" leader I caught a 44lb. blue cat at a little before one in the afternoon. Either next day or the day after, same spot, same cast, uni smallmouth. I was in disbelief when I pulled this up, thought my beer was making me see things as it was getting pretty late lol.
June 15, 20188 yr https://youtu.be/JSCsFCQ-oIoFarming pike at saint croix for days. Out of the blue get a uni brown trout Edited June 15, 20188 yr by Onemootime
June 15, 20188 yr I have caught several that have surprised me, but the last was an 11+ pound "Trophy" walleye fishing the tiger muskie area around Sandy Cape. I've never caught anything but uni once they surpassed the 11 lb. threshold on walleye.
June 16, 20188 yr I don't know if this would be considered odd per se, but one of my most unexpected catches came when I was fishing for brook trout, casting in the typical uni brook area, and hooked a 10.75 lb unique lake whitefish instead. It was my first whitefish, and remains my largest.
June 16, 20188 yr Tarpon by the overturned boat in FL. Using my jigwinner in the tiger trout spot and reeling in a 21 lb unique walleye.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.