Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Fishing Planet Forum

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Can´t catch Walleye in NY

Featured Replies

Hi,

I cant catch Walleye in NY, i was there for 3 days.
Weather condition, rainy, shinny, foggy at morning evenings and nights.
Shads, narrow spoon in different colours, small minnows. hooks eveything from #1/0 to #3/0.
Straight slow with twitching, stop and go.

I have been cathing everything else except walleye. Trophys aswell.

What am i doing wrong?

Best Regards.

I was at my wits end trying to get one. No matter what I tried I couldn't get a walleye.

And then I had 4 in 4 casts on 1/3rd ounce casting spoon.

Not been back since apart from a perch competition, because there's nothing to interest me. But, the known spot apparently is aiming just to the left of the tallest tree opposite you from the dock of peace. Alghough the 4 I had came from casting along the reeds to the right.

You've got me curious now, may go and try to catch one. But then again, the thought of filling a 154lb keepnet on that lake to make money..

  • Author

Nice, have been trying that too. right side ~120 feet, deep water. near the bushes,
Left side, close, around the bushes and further. 

Yupp filling up 154lb with ~3lb walleyes can be pain.

 

6 hours ago, djsaba said:
6 hours ago, djsaba said:

Nice, have been trying that too. right side ~120 feet, deep water. near the bushes,
Left side, close, around the bushes and further. 

Yupp filling up 154lb with ~3lb walleyes can be pain.

 

^^ This and I will add use Narrow spoons, hold rod down and just do a strait reel with no jigging. You will get Walleye and nice northern pike on the right side 120 plus feet, near the bushes. Morning and evening is best time.
 

 

I've found the red medium spoon 1/4oz. 1/0 works great on non-rainy days. The Amolite (purple) narrow spoon 1/4oz. 1/0 works great in the rain The lemon tiger medium spoon works in the rain too. I can't seem to get anything on the narrow black spoon which I've also seen recommended. Using minnows setting depth to 90-99 has worked for me.

Either lift n drop or stop n go work great. You can pretty much catch walleye all over the lake past 100 ft on dry days. I have caught some as close as 80 ft but that happens less often. On rainy days I've caught them as close as 40 ft from the dock. The best couple spots I've found are the spot to the right at the end of the bushes and the other is casting to the tall slender tree just to the left of the biggest tree straight out from the dock.

20170920_123450.jpg

20170920_123428.jpg

Edited by xBigfoot-86

I couldn't catch them hardly at all either. I just relied on pike until I could get to Florida. The bass there have done well for me.

Use live bait as a small minnow , hook #1/0 - and 250 cm leader length , go left spot, make ur shot right side of wood to directly . About 40-50 m away

Fish don't bite between 9pm and 5am.

Why? No idea. But fast forwarding time during that timeframe is free.

 

Edit: if you cast before 9pm you can still get a bite. If you cast after 9pm...good luck. There are very occasional fish to be caught, but basically 9pm to 5am you're wasting your time. Devs should fix this, or restrict fishing times.

PC players were lamenting this in 2015, and it's still a thing.

Edited by Violentvole

  • Author
10 hours ago, Violentvole said:

Fish don't bite between 9pm and 5am.

Why? No idea. But fast forwarding time during that timeframe is free.

Fishes bait aswell at night, i got a few of them. not often but they do bite.

12 hours ago, Caneria39 said:

Use live bait as a small minnow , hook #1/0 - and 250 cm leader length , go left spot, make ur shot right side of wood to directly . About 40-50 m away

I used that to until i changed my to 65 inches/165 cm leader depth and #2/0 hook,  then something happened, +1.5 kg Walleye. 

16 hours ago, xBigfoot-86 said:

I've found the red medium spoon 1/4oz. 1/0 works great on non-rainy days. The Amolite (purple) narrow spoon 1/4oz. 1/0 works great in the rain The lemon tiger medium spoon works in the rain too. I can't seem to get anything on the narrow black spoon which I've also seen recommended. Using minnows setting depth to 90-99 has worked for me.

Either lift n drop or stop n go work great. You can pretty much catch walleye all over the lake past 100 ft on dry days. I have caught some as close as 80 ft but that happens less often. On rainy days I've caught them as close as 40 ft from the dock. The best couple spots I've found are the spot to the right at the end of the bushes and the other is casting to the tall slender tree just to the left of the biggest tree straight out from the dock.

20170920_123428.jpg

I have been using purple aswell, and other colours. no luck but will try your method.
On this picture where you pointing your rod have i been luck whit 65 inches deepth and 120 feet out (small minnows).

17 hours ago, czoomx1 said:

^^ This and I will add use Narrow spoons, hold rod down and just do a strait reel with no jigging. You will get Walleye and nice northern pike on the right side 120 plus feet, near the bushes. Morning and evening is best time.

I will do that, slow or normal speed?


Thank you all.  =)
 

36 minutes ago, Violentvole said:

 

Edited. Someone just caught a walleye in the comp.

 

How much point u hit ? 

I did terrible, didn't catch anything until I found the pickerel with 7 minutes left. Definitely need some practice on that lake.

I did have a walleye though TC ( which didn't count in the comp unfortunately ), so they are still in there.

I hit 120 points but it didnt enougth , the first one 230 or something like that . If they are 40 lvl , ofc they have rod and reel advantage . Try to use shiners , on #2/0 hook and 100 cm leader length, and of course rigth side brushess

Yep, that's exactly what I used dude. Only fished there twice before so will have to spend some time on there and get to know it.

5 hours ago, djsaba said:
5 hours ago, djsaba said:

On this picture where you pointing your rod have i been luck whit 65 inches deepth and 120 feet out (small minnows).
 


I've had really good luck in that area too with minnows. I usually go deeper but I'll try about 65 ft. I'm getting some now out at about 165 ft as well.

 

  • Author

Damn this compitition was hard. i managed only 90p.
yeah those walleyes start hookig like nothing now.
Thank you all again.

-"If you need prof of night fishing time that hooks tell me i will post a image up here".

  • 11 months later...

Here's something I tried while looking for those unique Sauger.  Day or night, for whatever reason they will hit the 30ft 6/0 glowing night crank.  If you don't have that lure, buy it... Believe me, it's worth it.  About 20 feet approximately from that big rock to the left.  I was in a kayak, so you'll probably need one to get there, but I'm telling you, I must have caught 10 in a few days up there.  Good fight and they are a Walleye species, just a cousin.

833678659_uniquesauger.thumb.jpg.c060e11a84cf80e27ce0433011ba8bac.jpg

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.