Yes,
Sadly its been severely nerfed.
I did this 2 years ago on my other account and only got the roach spoon on day 12, but at least it was possible. (on my other account I have 46 roach spoons now )
This time I have visited 232 pumpkins/tombs in 11 days and have 6 bony shads, 9 Skull Jigs, 8 Silicon Spiders and 0 roach spoon and 0 spider spoon
Categorically nerfed.
However, one final thought....
If you do spend the 99 baitcoins on the DLC, get the lures you need to finish, complete the mission, you can then sell you prize (Monstrosity Kayak, terrible piece of junk) for 100 baitcoins!
Result - Mission finished with a profit of 1 baitcoin!
We can beat the system!