when you catch the 10 monsters you are rewarded with 5 Frankenbait. If it's anything like the invisible line challenge if you run out of Frankenbait then the mission to catch 10 monsters will open back up and then you will again be rewarded with the Frankenbait.
If you haven't caught Mad-eye yet I got mine yesterday. I spawned in at Dam Road. If you're looking at the map I went to the left toward the rocks and moved into the clearing in front of it. I chose a day that had top peak at noon and used Semolina Balls. I believe I used a depth of 35 inches. My coordinates for him were 19.05, 32.39.