I wonder if all of the event fish behave in the same way. The highly visible Ghost Pike provides some interesting information about how the fish spawning works.
Fishing in the old Muskie spot in Michigan and casting a float into 'Muskie Corner', we were able to get about 4 per hour during peak time new moon.
The following patterns were observed by us.
1. Even though no pike had visually spawned, the float did it's usual moving around as though a fish was present.
2. If no fish had spawned after 1 minute of the cast, it was best to recast, we tried leaving it for around 30 minutes with no success.
3. Only one fish spawned at a time, at no time was there more than one visible.
4. Depth was critical 24 inches in high pressure (+/-2).
5. Bait shiner, large minnows or rotten minnows, all worked the same.
Given point 3, If you want to increase your chances, fish in a private room, not ideal for a 'fun' event.