Have you checked to make sure your reel speed isn't at 4? In the reel icon in the bottom right corner of the screen, there are chevrons (arrow tops) to indicate what reel speed you are using. Pressing up on the d-pad will raise it, pressing down will lower it. If the Chevron gets to the point that it is pointing down, and is only an outline as opposed to being white, it means that you are in reverse, and will let line out instead of reeling in