Reading through the posts has me convinced that you're misunderstanding the challenge. You don't need to cast over a certain distance a specific number of times. In order to complete the challenge, you have to cast the specified distance once.
To clarify, right now I'm working on completing 'Long Caster II'. It shows 84/100. The 84 represents my longest cast to date, measuring by yards. The 100 is the distance, in yards, that I need to cast in order to complete the challenge.