I think I figured this out. It's not lifting rods off the stand it's swapping rods. Something is going on that creates slack in the line that I never had a problem with before today. The upshot being that you can't fish an extra rod.
Grinding exp on Win10 in Blue Crab after updating this morning I'm losing probably 1 in 4 fish lifting the rod off the quad stand. Having so recently done the same thing on Steam this can't be right. It's making the game unplayable.