January 12, 20197 yr So i just finished a comp, a 45 minute catfish one in Louisiana ._ caught fish all the way thru, and the top guy had double my score! My point being is there some ai predetermined before a comp starts? If there isnt then sometin real fishy is goin on. No pun intended._.
January 12, 20197 yr Which species of cat were you fishing for? The species in this comp have different multipliers per lb/kg. As far as scores go seems normal for a sunny day and pretty sure the top 10 are people not bots
January 12, 20197 yr The game seems to favor certain players randomly. I feel like during those times if I capitalize on the opportunities I will do well. However, there are plenty of times the game makes me feel like it is my first time fishing the comp. Example, today I fished Old Buck's for 15 min no fish would take my shiners (ping and swim away), tried spawnsac just to get something-anything, still fish nibbled then left, quickstrikes failed. I had around 14 points with about 10 minutes left. I know this comp, usually score around 1K or better each time, had some bad ones, but this takes the cake. I even restarted the game with no change in results. This is just nuts, seriously. Makes no sense, leaders were at 700 and 800 points respectively when I quit.
January 12, 20197 yr 14 minutes ago, iGoshawk said: The game seems to favor certain players randomly. I feel like during those times if I capitalize on the opportunities I will do well. However, there are plenty of times the game makes me feel like it is my first time fishing the comp. Example, today I fished Old Buck's for 15 min no fish would take my shiners (ping and swim away), tried spawnsac just to get something-anything, still fish nibbled then left, quickstrikes failed. I had around 14 points with about 10 minutes left. I know this comp, usually score around 1K or better each time, had some bad ones, but this takes the cake. I even restarted the game with no change in results. This is just nuts, seriously. Makes no sense, leaders were at 700 and 800 points respectively when I quit. A few have had issues with bites in old bucks for a while im trying to stay clear of live bait there until around unis spawning times the constant dings can be anoying as hell
January 13, 20197 yr 17 hours ago, Thunderbane5079 said: caught fish all the way thru, and the top guy had double my score! Welcome to Fishing Planet! ? From my experience: if you can manage to get half the score of the top guys, you're doing pretty good. After that, it's all about finding more spots, and getting the quick strike down (correct me if I'm wrong). The more I play this game, the more I realize that it's just not possible to cope with the top 20 players if you don't use quick strike in every. damn. competition. Be it moonlight gars, sturgeon in the dark, all the catfish comps, Old Bucks, One By One, whatever.. if you don't use quick strike, you're gonna have a hard time getting close to the top scores. (Again, please correct me if I'm wrong.) In some comps (esp. One By One) I even think it can be a lot of fun! That competition is exhausting, but it's nice to see your score increase everytime you play it. Personally, I believe that it's a mistake they ever put the quick strike this in the game. It ruins a lot of game mechanics for me. Like thinking about what hook size you should use, what bait they like best, using bigger bait for bigger fish, using live bait for more attraction, etc. But everybody has his its own opinion about that. And it's in the game, so.. No cheating here.. And it takes a lot of skill and concentration to get it down. So kudos to the guys that take this to perfection. As for the catfish trial, there's a spot where you can reel em in from 16 metres or so (only works on rainy weather, as far as I know). Use that spot and the quick strike, and you might see your score improve. 17 hours ago, Thunderbane5079 said: My point being is there some ai predetermined before a comp starts? 35 minutes ago, iGoshawk said: The game seems to favor certain players randomly. Well if you go to rankings > competitions, take a close look at the top 20 or so players, and then check the competition's results, you'll see that it's always the same names in the top 10. Which brings me to the assumption that it's neither luck-based (or RNG, as they say), nor pre-calculated (as some people have 2, 3 or 4 accounts, that they manage to get into the top 10 as well). It's about knowledge and technique (and, of course, a lot of free-time, in order to play a lot, do research, take notes, and improve your score). 1 hour ago, iGoshawk said: Example, today I fished Old Buck's for 15 min no fish would take my shiners (ping and swim away), tried spawnsac just to get something-anything, still fish nibbled then left, quickstrikes failed. I had around 14 points with about 10 minutes left. I know this comp, usually score around 1K or better each time, had some bad ones, but this takes the cake. I even restarted the game with no change in results. This is just nuts, seriously. Makes no sense, leaders were at 700 and 800 points respectively when I quit. I played that competition as well. Same for me. A lot of nibbling, but no bites. #1/0, #2/0, Large Minnows, Shiners, 80cm, 90cm, 60cm.. I caught two uniques, but all in all too little fish. Tried Spawn Sack and quick strike for the last 5 minutes, and it worked out pretty well. I'll give that a shot for the next Old Buck's. I'm pretty sure you can't score 680 - 694 points in that competition with live bait, looking at your bobber, and waiting for the fish to strike. But then again, I might be wrong ? Personally, I'd love to see how that competition evolves with spinning only. Trying to catch some tiny ass golden trout with your Featherlight and a barbless spinner.. ?
January 13, 20197 yr 18 hours ago, Thunderbane5079 said: So i just finished a comp, a 45 minute catfish one in Louisiana ._ caught fish all the way thru, and the top guy had double my score! My point being is there some ai predetermined before a comp starts? If there isnt then sometin real fishy is goin on. No pun intended._. Unfortunately - and I've said this since I started playing and yet to be rebuked - everything you know about the game is irrelevant when it comes to competitions. They have their own, different, rules and the only way to learn is to compete and learn. Some of the guys here do that, and they have my respect for putting the time in. Others use multiple accounts to play the same competition several times over and over to maximise their chances of placing. They do not have my respect. In essence, to stand a chance in competitions and tourneys you have to learn 2 different games. This has long been a bugbear of mine - everything I have learnt about the game becomes redundant in a competition. Some of the top players will just say I'm jealous. I'm really not, I don't do comps anymore. Because they are total B/S. In any given competition, myself, BJtater, Hateful, Tmif and loads of others should stand a good chance given our combined knowledge. Instead, everything we know becomes redundant. The last I heard, a competition should have a random winner. FP competitions do not fit that description.
January 13, 20197 yr For a good example of what FP competitions are, research Chaos Theory. VV is right that comps have their own rules. However I disagree (very respectfully!) that a comp should have a random winner. Remember it is a computer system, 0's and 1's and algorithms and such. The players you see always at the top, even the multiple account/device cheaters, have put in the time to reduce their inefficiencies and maximize their optimum fishing times. The same 10 players everyone always sees at the top have it broken down by weather and minute. 5 PM on a cloudy day fish X spot with X lure. Catch a trophy, move to Y spot and use Y lure, etc. This will get you a higher floor on your performance but RNG still plays a factor. Those guys have bad days too but we only remember when they are on the leaderboard(confirmation bias). I only have 3 wins and was getting pretty good at the Perch one before I quit doing them. Seemed like work to me when I just wanted to have fun.
January 13, 20197 yr 10 hours ago, alohastone said: I played that competition as well. Same for me. A lot of nibbling, but no bites. #1/0, #2/0, Large Minnows, Shiners, 80cm, 90cm, 60cm.. I caught two uniques, but all in all too little fish. Tried Spawn Sack and quick strike for the last 5 minutes, and it worked out pretty well. I'll give that a shot for the next Old Buck's. I'm pretty sure you can't score 680 - 694 points in that competition with live bait, looking at your bobber, and waiting for the fish to strike. But then again, I might be wrong ? Yeh the spawn sacks work very well iv had 2 old bucks comp part cloudy where i had ding after ding. Sunny day seems fine still. Lucky there are many spots even in the area to the left. Altho i started on live bait i knew id missed the 1st uni swiched to spawnsacks quikestriked until i knew the next uni would be spawning then swiched back to live for last 4 fish and got the last uni luckly without phantom dings i finished 7th or 8th and final placed 18 in the end not as good as id of hoped but i think last two atemps part cloudy i think i was around 40 50 marker Edited January 13, 20197 yr by kylerobz
January 13, 20197 yr Quikstriking is definetly dominant in alot of comps now where most would of used livebait ( or some cases spinning gear) to acheive the score and even get the fish we need eg: unis. There are fish that if we dont strike on first bite we dont get another chance at it the fish goes and we get left waiting on the next ding, each of them missed dings is missed points and if ure in and out the water catching your gona be hearing mor dings than on livebait most of the time. More dings = more fish. 1 fact that carnt be denied. The rest is just learning how to succeed in multiplying the dings in the alotted time and not missing
January 13, 20197 yr Well guys, you dont need to use quikestryke to win comps, maybe just in one by one yes...i win extravaganza with no quikestrike, the same with peacoke in florida, i score 51 kg without quikestrike, i win moonlight gar without quikestrike, old buck dont need quickstrike defenetly, quikestrike is good for one by one and comps of catfish, but when the game give you the fish you dont need use always quikestrike, you need is find another spots.
January 13, 20197 yr And when you have a ding and a ding and a ding and he dont bite, normaly something is wrong with your config, maybee baits, depth etc... try change something, and sometimes is realy the game want give you anythink..my advice , you think you know all spot in comp ? Wrong, even me or rotacomando or happyassassin , all weeks i discover new spots for comps and after that i must update how to do...yesterday i give some spot to igoshawk trying improve extravaganza, and he was amazed with all spot to do it, now he must train and certainly he will improve, so i repeat find spot , try diferent baits , and the time clock is crucial and dont forgot , the weather, dont do the same , an example extravaganza in sunny day is diferent on partial day , normaly this rule is for all comp, diferent weather in same comp is diferent way to do that and must players do the same.. is totally wrong Edited January 13, 20197 yr by Rodrigoskybox
January 13, 20197 yr Here is how I really feel about all of this. I love this game, the competitions, and just plain having this game as a substitute for Real fishing. Now, when it comes to comps, I do not believe the game is out to get me, or that it favors certain people. If people want to use multi accounts or cheat or whatever, then fine. Just remember being great and being a great cheater are not the same. In the end, the cheater knows they cheated and in their heart, their scores are not genuine. Cheaters have to live with being a cheater, until they stop. No sweat off my back. When I get bad results in comps it really stinks because I am so competitive. I am a competitor at heart and just can't get enough of these fishing comps. So here is the moral of the story: I quit that comp and went and ate dinner, I lost 15 points X[ - but I went ahead and did the bowfin comp (which was next) and got a new pb score and earned 6 points. I will not stop doing these comps, even if I have a terrible result on occasion. Here is my theory on comps: do them, do lots of them, keep doing them, keep your head up even when things go bad, keep doing comps, keep learning, and keep having fun - good results will become consistent with this method of being competitive. You have to put in the time to start to place good in comps or even win (I have 3 wins). Even after you have won a comp, don't expect to keep those results each time you play. After a while you become better at turning bad days around. If comps is why you play this game and you hate the way comps go, then quit. If you starting playing this game for fun, found more fun in the game by competiting, and then get frustrated with comps, just go back to fishing. I may express concern about certain things here with the game, but overall I love it. I will not stop playing comps, I will not stop playing because of cheaters, and I will not stop playing cause I don't win. Edited January 13, 20197 yr by iGoshawk ...
January 13, 20197 yr Thats why i said most of the time i agree peacock and gar and even for me bucks on sunny day ok. Maybe you dont under stand what i mean by more dings = more fish, even knowing spot,gear, etc by the time it can take fish to bite you can already be on next bite with quikstrike thus givin a higher score. I agree on all you say about changing it up regularly i definetly have much better results unfortunatly i dont practice often and prefer to fish leasurely when not in comps plus i have a terrible memory and dont keep notes(thank god for marker boyes) havent realy got goals in comp just the enjoyment of competing is enough for me, but when i have practiced and competed i have definetly noticed better results in quikstriking especialy in the last few minutes no way regardless of setup them extra few fish arnt being landed without quikstike. There has been many times iv had fish in final seconds thanks to quikstrike.
January 13, 20197 yr 1 hour ago, Rodrigoskybox said: And when you have a ding and a ding and a ding and he dont bite, normaly something is wrong with your config, maybee baits, depth etc... try change something, and sometimes is realy the game want give you anythink..my advice , you think you know all spot in comp ? Wrong, even me or rotacomando or happyassassin , all weeks i discover new spots for comps and after that i must update how to do...yesterday i give some spot to igoshawk trying improve extravaganza, and he was amazed with all spot to do it, now he must train and certainly he will improve, so i repeat find spot , try diferent baits , and the time clock is crucial and dont forgot , the weather, dont do the same , an example extravaganza in sunny day is diferent on partial day , normaly this rule is for all comp, diferent weather in same comp is diferent way to do that and must players do the same.. is totally wrong Rodrigo you are the best buddy. It will take me a while to put all you talked about into action, but you are awesome. Thank you very much.
January 13, 20197 yr Author I was fishing for both flats and blues, given i didnt catch any flat unis i was catching trophies of both with an occassional channel. I thought i did good until i saw some the other scores. Then i knew i had no chance._ i scored over 2000 with like 7 mins to go and these guys have over 5000. Wouldnt u pretty much have to catch a fish every min or so and then theres some u cant just pull outta the water? And ur rite, seems favortism is a factor most the time. It takes any fun out of a comp when stuff like that happens. Some games have ai in them and being these are all real ppl makes it even odder. Makes a person wonder sometimes because some of the comps dont even feel like comps esp when u pretty much know what the outcomes gonna b b4 it even starts. ...
January 14, 20197 yr 22 hours ago, Tmif said: For a good example of what FP competitions are, research Chaos Theory. VV is right that comps have their own rules. However I disagree (very respectfully!) that a comp should have a random winner. Remember it is a computer system, 0's and 1's and algorithms and such. The players you see always at the top, even the multiple account/device cheaters, have put in the time to reduce their inefficiencies and maximize their optimum fishing times. The same 10 players everyone always sees at the top have it broken down by weather and minute. 5 PM on a cloudy day fish X spot with X lure. Catch a trophy, move to Y spot and use Y lure, etc. This will get you a higher floor on your performance but RNG still plays a factor. Those guys have bad days too but we only remember when they are on the leaderboard(confirmation bias). I only have 3 wins and was getting pretty good at the Perch one before I quit doing them. Seemed like work to me when I just wanted to have fun. While I accept the fact you disagree with me ( in the nicest possible way, thanks dude lol ), you inadvertently agree with me because what you state above shows that competitions are not true competitions. They should be completely random - every time. With every competitor in with the same chance of winning. Unfortunately, they are not. For lack of a better term, they're scripted. As you say, " go here at X Oclock, go there at XX Oclock " etc. True competitions, anyone would stand a chance. As it stands, only those who put in lots of time stand a chance. So how is that a competition? It's akin to placing the worst football team in America into a game against the best ( I realise this statement could cause discussion as to the best and worst, but bear with the analogy ) and calling it a fair game when the outcome is damn near a dead cert. Nobody should have knowledge that doesn't come from playing the regular game that sways competitions in their favour. There should be no such thing in a competition. Yet there is. Competitions should reflect what we learn while playing the game and allow us to use those skills to stand a chance, yet they don't. Not aimed at you in particular T, nor at the top competition guys, more a statement on the ridiculousness of the system. Not even sure if I'm making sense anymore, time to open another beer and put my head in the oven.
January 14, 20197 yr 59 minutes ago, Violentvole said: True competitions, anyone would stand a chance. As it stands, only those who put in lots of time stand a chance. Maybe I am misunderstanding what you mean by "stand a chance". In any sport, those that put in the time to practice will have an advantage over those who do not. Believe me, I am not a fan of the way the competitions are structured. I have sent enough emails to FP on the subject that my username is probably considered a dirty word around the dev's offices. Should they be less "paint by numbers"? Absolutely. Although I did win the Midnight Salmon by somehow catching a 40lb. uni chum. Straight luck. Like I said, I quit doing them because it was scripted as you say. When I see "anyone stand a chance", that brings to my mind a lottery ticket. I'm sure there is some middle ground shade of grey sweet spot that FP is working on for these comps that we'll get right after the new update(lol). At least we can disagree without being disagreeable.
January 14, 20197 yr 1 hour ago, Violentvole said: Not even sure if I'm making sense anymore, time to open another beer and put my head in the oven. when i read that i took the pistol out of my mouth and said "WOW! THAT'S IT!!" (because i would not have been able to understand what i said without removing the gun first) i started in 2016 and have over 2000hrs in game, but i've only done 5 or 6 comps. why? they don't .... make .... sense! i catch more than in normal play. that don't make sense. the winner got 3-4X more. that don't make sense. he would need to catch an avg size fish every minute of the comp. that don't make sense. AI? cheaters? hackers? rng? perfect players? none of it makes sense to me. so i don't bother lol
January 14, 20197 yr why are they so far from making us create are own comps. we can go against friends and go against some players we can have fueds with. it will get us to get to know different players creating a relationships with fisherman. id suggest 12 players comps making are chances alot better. an id love to make are own stipulations. in the future we need fewer players in comps and why not run em all day? they feed us just enough to keep us happy but comps must make alot of improvements. An if clubs are ever introduced we can neglect the players with cheating speculations and compete with players of are skill level and play against friends . Finally going head to head comps we could double are money with a win an also win more if more players are signed in the comps Edited January 14, 20197 yr by tombomb79
January 14, 20197 yr 5 hours ago, tombomb79 said: why are they so far from making us create are own comps. we can go against friends and go against some players we can have fueds with. it will get us to get to know different players creating a relationships with fisherman. id suggest 12 players comps making are chances alot better. an id love to make are own stipulations. in the future we need fewer players in comps and why not run em all day? they feed us just enough to keep us happy but comps must make alot of improvements. An if clubs are ever introduced we can neglect the players with cheating speculations and compete with players of are skill level and play against friends . Finally going head to head comps we could double are money with a win an also win more if more players are signed in the comps Creating our iwn comps will be the top.
January 14, 20197 yr +1 custom comps however look at the history of the game and take a look at steam forum. With all the issues, updates,new content amongst a few thing. How many dayly complaints, problems, issues regarding comps alone the devs must be recieving with no fix. It seems easy when spoken but think logical, sorry to say this but the devs struggle to keep up with our issues on 1 setting. How many variation would we have when customizing? The state of the update so far the devs would be very ballsy to atemp to allow our own comps. I can see the writing on the wall aready Complement, complement, complaint,complaint, complaint,complaint.......... Some actions of the devs may be very foolish. But stupid they are not. Anyone with a braincell would not even atempt to implement such a thing with what is already overhanging on them greatly.
January 14, 20197 yr Feel free to argue my point but i garantee if new content drops for us next week this forum will be full of rage by the weekend
January 15, 20197 yr Author Not to change the subject but i guess this could fall into complaints or whatever...I was looking at the weekly stat boards and as i looked em over i was looking at everyones totals of fish caught and such, idk why but ive not caught anything what all others have caught. Ive always felt that i had a huge bug problem.. I have excessive lag, constant problems being able to control lures, and i horrible bite system. I mean ive caught aroun 11000 fish or so total. Of that 11000 only 160 uniques. Ive looked at tons of other peoples numbers and every single 1 blows me out of the water, either im the worst player in the world or somethings wrong between the server and my system and, or even thought my internet my b at fault. Reason being i dont have wired internet nor what id call wifi..I have to use my cell as a hotspot and bounce off its wifi signal... Anyhow am hoping sum1 might have advice or may be experiencing something like this.. If you have any input plz let me know. Thanks
January 15, 20197 yr Yeh this got mentioned a few weeks ago my internet is very poor. Since i managed to get a wired connection in my sons room start of december altho the connection is stil poor due to my provider i definetly started to have less miss strikes without a doubt. I use to teather from a phone years ago when i first started bo2 and it was hurendous ( not a clue how to spell it sorry?) so i can imagine what it must be like for you. But i wouldnt say that being the reason for low amount of unis tho. I love fishing for unis most of the time i only fish uni timezones just my prefference to have fun ingame, hence the reason i started playing comps (most comps are uni timezones) and before anyone jumps on the band wagon i did just say MOST.
January 15, 20197 yr 6 hours ago, Thunderbane5079 said: I have to use my cell as a hotspot and bounce off its wifi signal... Anyhow am hoping sum1 might have advice or may be experiencing something like this.. If you have any input plz let me know. Thanks I would test your connection speeds in your PS4's network settings, chances are they're too slow. If your in a bad area where your signal is weak to begin with, contact your carrier about a signal booster. Some carriers will send it to you for free if you're in a qualifying area. There are third party companies that make LTE boosters, but they can get expensive.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.