Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Fishing Planet Forum

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Monster Carp School

Featured Replies

Monster Carp School convened one day after big bro Eluce won Fishing Planet's Steam Mighty Carp Finals 2021 . . .

BHPtxuG.png
Dramatic embellishment of our conversations in game and Discord using a screenshot from big bro Eluce.

  • Author

Welcome to Monster Carp School
Hosted by Professor Musette
with Steam Carp Lord Eluce

F0rqmOT.png

Part 1: Theories and Themes

Theories are just ideas waiting to be tested and replicated. Theories are not made out of thin air. Theories are patterns that you explore through extensive research. Some theories are difficult to unify with current meta models. Some meta models are flawed because they are less than optimal. Other meta models become outdated with new gear or Dev patching. Also bear in mind, theories can be wrapped in programming holes which @PH_Carpman99 refers to as: Undocumented Features. Sometimes you just gotta use your gut feeling. Also bear in mind, my theories and methods evolve daily. Unless you are in continual contact with me, I may have optimized a method further.

I don't publish regularly or feel like I should publish everything I test as I hear my theories can cause brain injuries and spread sheet overload. I don't use spread sheets. I keep the data I investigate as screenshots and memorize the data in musical notation. It's easier for me  to see and hear patterns, filters, dissonances and algorithms in musical notation than on a 2D spread sheet platform. I can also memorize, extrapolate and counterpoint more data in music notation than Eluce, Average and Jim Kaf can store on their volumes of spread sheets combined. I just think a little differently than you guys because I have an early background in music, dance and science. The battle cry of anyone with a background in music or dance is: PRACTICE!

(Trigger warning for Eluce. The following San Joaquin data collecting sheet may hurt your brain.)
JUA8tpC.png

Brother Eluce can't quantify what I am testing unless he actually goes fishing in the same instance as me. Remember when Brother Jim came over to my instance on FP and tried to disprove my research on carp nibbling patterns? He ended-up proving that carp nibbling is NOT random when using his scrap mix. Brother Jim could not see that his scrap mix produced 5 brown carp at once. He could only see what was on the rod he picked-up. Once Jim saw the screenshot of the multiple brownies nibbling his rods, he understood that his scrap mix had potential to be tweaked to Jolly Carp conditions to target mostly 40kg brownies.
2qyeDkn.png

Brother Eluce and I have similar recipes on The Fisherman and Fishing Planet. We both developed our mixes through tons of research. Even though we took separate paths, we landed on the same page. The Carp Lord and The Professor might argue and challenge each other but I always enjoy throwing ideas back and forth with Big Bro. Plus, I have permission to meme him mercilessly only because the dude enjoys pranking me in game!

 

  • Author

Part 2: Monster Mix PHaT Boosting  

PHaT: Urban slang for Pretty Hot and Thick. A hip way to describe an awesome electric bass line or a bootylicious superstar like Beyonce.

So how do we drop the bass to create phat monster carp?

The reason Eluce can catch 2-3x 40-48kg mobys back to back is that his MCT mix flips a typical carp school of:
2x Large (trophy or uni)
2-3x Medium
Multiple smallies

TO:

2 Moby Uni
2-3x Unis (or 4-5x medium uni if no mobys)
Multiple trophies and smallies

Some waterways include multiple carp schools of varyious types like Bighead, Silver, Mirror, Leather, Common, Grass, Ghost and minnow carp.(*note: https://wiki.fishingplanet.com/Carp_family)

These carp can form an entourage college of multiple schools which respond to the same groundbait dependent of hook size, hookbait, depth presentation (leader length of match, bottom or carp rods), hookbait shape, hookbait size, and hookbait bait color. This is how you can have a monster mix which produces both huge bottom carp and topwater carp. Topwater carp aren't designed for bottom feeding groundbait. However, the Devs appear to have simulated an entourage effect where:

Monster GB produces multiple PHaT bottom carp
->which produce phat waste,
->which feed the plankton and algae,
->which the Topwater carp feed on.

For instance, in San Joachim on Beaver Island, the entourage effect with Musette's Germany Mix + Eluce's Germany monster mix can flip 2 carp schools from:

4x large (trophy or uni)
8x medium
multiple young and minnows

TO:

4 moby common carp unis of 25kg-32kg
2-8 medium uni
multiple trophies and regulars

Typically, that same area with a low aroma monster mix produces only:
2 large uni in the 25-30ish kg range (if you are lucky...most people catch only 1)
4 trophies
multiple regulars
a few young

Placeholders for trophy and uni carp show up as large fish on the sonar scan:
T8JK8zv.png

You want to let all trophy and regular carp escape by relaxing the drag on your rod. This way you don't deplete the limited amount of trophies that can be flipped into a uni.

Both my TF Germany mix and Eluce's mix are identical except for one aroma swap.

The feeders used are Carp Rival, Catfish Destroyer, Big Riverne Breamer totaling 2500g.

3 aromas each totaling 9.99% or 3.33% each.  Combining our mixes gives us 2x aromas @ 3.33% and 2x aromas @1.62%.  Both of us use Tutti Frutti and Giant Octo which is common in most of my mixes. The last aroma controls temperature range and enhances either sweet, spicy, or complex flavor profiles of hookbait. Different aromas can be swapped out to make interesting combinations that favor brownies more or larger caspers, 420s and commons. Have fun combining different aromas. Welcome to Musette and Eluce's Monster Mash-up Halloween Party with 4 aroma bass line boost.

2 or more particles as close to 15% are important to speed-up and sustain feeding interest.

Mash your monster mixing with a knowledge of which pellet and boillie flavors and colors certain species favor, and lots of practice, and you'll be able to score well in all carp competitions on both Fishing Planet and The Fisherman.

There are other monster mixes that use less aroma percentages that generate big monster spike numbers, but they might not spike the entire school into the PHat range.  Eluce and Musette's Germany mixes can flip the values of all large and medium placeholders to the Phat Range while generating feeding frenzy. However, mileage may vary on Fishing Planet in regular instances as the devs may change the filter values of waterways to add challenge and variety (which seems to annoy fishers more than inspire them to switch tactics or waterways). You notice the difference more when comparing the same waterway, spot and environmental conditions between Fishing Planet and The Fisherman. The environmental filters on The Fisherman remain constant unless preprogrammed to change with the seasons.

 

  • Author

Part 3: Practical Applications for Phat Bass Propagation in Carp Competitions
(Note: Brother Eluce does not agree with all of my findings because he has his own winning methods. I don't test competitions as much because of lag issues but I do have other competitors test my methods when I can't do them myself. The main point to understand is, on Fishing Planet where the Devs can change fish algorithms and filters at every update, you want additional strategies for those times when your favorite mix falls short on a Dev patch. This is why I encourage people to experiment like Musette mashing her mix with Eluce when both mixes alone are mediocre on a different waterway under different environmental conditions. Learn when to drop a mix, tactic or fishing spot to transition to another more fruitful mix, tactic or fishing spot. That's the real secret of a champion.)

How does this BS PHaT theory help with competitions?

C'mon, Carp is the most obvious competition to force only uniques to spawn in one spot. Never ever reel in trophies. Then get a .5kg young carp first with an 8mm pellet and #10-#6 regular hook under the Southern Dock.

Spoiler

ZTisoH9.png

Also see the previous post for creel and telemetry data of one of my carping spots in San Joaquin.

Open spoiler for easy young common carp retrieval info.

Lucky Ghost: If your mix can filter 420 and casper range, then start with catching a moby ghost carp and depleting the school of unis. Once the phat uni placeholders are depleted, the next phat range size grouping with a #10/0-#14/0 hook is 13kg-14kg trophies. Jim Kaf gave me this idea with his insistence of using the largest hook only, rather than swapping to a smaller hook to catch the lucky trophy casper. I just exploited Jim Kaf's stubbornness by depleting the school of unis placeholders which left only 13-14kg trophy placeholders with a PHat mix.

Jolly Carp: Only need 2-3 spots where you know 2 or more carp schools swim together. Do not reel in trophies, caspers or 420s. A good spot can produce 2-4 monsters. You should move to another spot once you pull-up 2 to let your mix regenerate 2 more monsters. When you reel in trophies, wrong species monsters, and small unis, you deplete the schools of generating potential mobys.

For the record, I experimented with Jolly Carp on The Fisherman and accidentally won. Was not expecting success with this experiment because I can't confirm school potential without sonar data. Remember, TF is about 1.5 years behind Fishing Planet, so the max range for Jolly Carp uni is between 32-35kg with a size #10/0 hook.  In the evening, I fished all the leftover uni because the prize is a buggy X-braid that breaks with every cast. I honestly did try to let the other guys catch-up. The Musette/Eluce mash-up was used. Not bad for a 45 minute, limited school template farm. 416 baitcoins and 1 troll X-braid! Please get Eluce Jr. to level 50 to help me experiment on TF big bro...just beware of the buggy X-braid prize.
AZOS6zS.png

Grass Cutter: Check the competition leader board at the half way mark. If you see people struggling to with getting 2x 420, that means the competition hours of 2am-4am, the waterway have filters that favor orange colors and a sweet, tangy ripe fruit profile.  I believe Grass Cutter has a built in seasonal shift that mimics spawning season and harvest season. I've only seen these conditions during Grass Cutter. You can create a 2nd spod that mimics both orange egg color and harvest aroma by enhancing the ground spod with tangy, orange pineapple pellets between 2am-4am. When the sky brightens at 4am, 420 carp return to their meta flavor of shrimp. Most people are stuck trying to stimulate carp to feed during the first 30 minutes of the competition. They can only get carp to feed in the last 15 minutes of the competition when the sky brightens at 4am. I usually win the competition within the first 20 minutes by hooking a 27-32kg grass carp @ [130,54] and then a small grass carp. I spend the last 35 minutes either fishing a smaller or larger 420 carp depending on the other carpers ability to fish-up moby 420s. Don't deplete the school by reeling in other uni species or trophies. Keep pushing for a moby sized 420.

Spoiler

3FX34Cd.png

Open Spoiler for Musette's complete Grass Cutter strategy

FYI: Eluce

  • Do not reel in trophies or wrong species unis. Loosen the drag and let the carp escape or break the line and re-hook if you accidentally hook a moby of the wrong species. I know the Carp Lord lives to reel in 42kg+ mobies, but DON'T in this competition. This is not Jolly Carp or MCT. If you reel in that monster 48kg mirror in this competition, I will so disown you! Bad Carp Lord!

Danger in The Grass:
Let all trophy commons and brownies escape so you do not deplete the limited pool of potential phat trophy 420s.

Carp Foundation:
Because you are using a monster mix, you create a phat range for smaller hooks. Thusly, a #1/0 hook with a 20mm citrus boillie will generate trophies in the 6-10kg range and catch all remaining young and regulars when the trophies are depleted.

 

 

Part 4: Remixes (to be continued at a future date)

  • 1 month later...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.