December 6, 20223 yr I've been wondering about this. The game is extremely inaccurate concerning hooks used for carps. Nobody would ever think of using a huge butcher hook like a #0/10 on a poor carp. Hook sizes around #4 are the norm. Trouts, they are also fished with small hooks. Why such inaccuracy in a game that otherwise stays very close to realism? Maybe it is simply an implementation of bite probability (hook size / kg of fish)?
December 6, 20223 yr Yes, this topic has been brought up many times. I do believe it has mostly to do with the size of the hook relating to the size of the fish you catch (as you mentioned) and a 10/0 hook is something you'd be using for a very large fish (like a shark), any carp would feel the weight and bolt. You'd probably have more luck casting one without any bait and retrieving it (with some jerking motions thrown in) very quickly (actively trying to jag fish is not legal in the waterways I fish). I have no memory of ever seeing any information that this issue will be addressed in the future and so will remain as it is.
December 6, 20223 yr Author 1 hour ago, PH_Carpman99 said: I have no memory of ever seeing any information that this issue will be addressed in the future and so will remain as it is. A shame! An other funny thing is bighead carps. A hook so large wouldn't even fit into their mouths! They are meant to be fished with small hooks, that they accidentally suck in while the technoplankton or other bait dissolves. Oh well. In the end I am glad that this old game still gets updates.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.