I've been wondering about this.
The game is extremely inaccurate concerning hooks used for carps. Nobody would ever think of using a huge butcher hook like a #0/10 on a poor carp. Hook sizes around #4 are the norm.
Trouts, they are also fished with small hooks.
Why such inaccuracy in a game that otherwise stays very close to realism? Maybe it is simply an implementation of bite probability (hook size / kg of fish)?